Football is one of the most popular sports in New York, with high school teams from all over the state competing for titles. With the season in full swing, it’s time to take a look at the top 10 high school football teams in New York! This blog post will rank each team based on their performance this season, and will provide a brief overview of their strengths and weaknesses. So without further ado, let’s get into the rankings!
1# St. Anthony’s (Melville)
St. Anthony’s High School in Melville, NY is the top ranked team in the New York high school football rankings. This year they have a talented roster led by Senior QB Joe Cimino and senior WR Ryan Defeo. They’ve been on a roll since the beginning of the season, with a 7-1 record, their only loss coming to Iona Prep. They’re heading into the playoffs as the #1 seed in the conference, and look poised for a deep run in the playoffs.
2# Iona Prep (New Rochelle)
Iona Prep, located in New Rochelle, New York, is one of the top high school football programs in the state. The Gaels have been a consistent powerhouse for the past few years, with appearances in the New York State Catholic High School Athletic Association championship game four times in the last five seasons.
In 2016, Iona Prep won the Class AA state title, its first state championship since 1988. Led by current head coach Joe Spagnola, the Gaels have been consistent playoff contenders and consistently finish near the top of the rankings.
Offensively, Iona Prep is powered by the play of senior quarterback Rob Tannenbaum and senior running back Tyler Palma. Tannenbaum has thrown for over 1,000 yards and 13 touchdowns this season, while Palma has rushed for over 700 yards and seven scores. The Gaels have a solid supporting cast on offense as well, with junior wide receiver Dionte Middleton, senior tight end John Smith, and junior running back Ryan Tejada all contributing to the team’s success.
Defensively, Iona Prep is led by senior linebacker Shane Connelly and junior defensive tackle Steve Edmonds. Connelly has recorded 64 tackles, two sacks, and two forced fumbles this season, while Edmonds has tallied 33 tackles and four sacks. Other key contributors on defense include senior defensive back Michael O’Hagan and sophomore defensive end Michael Corrado.
Overall, Iona Prep is a talented and well-coached team that should be a contender in the playoffs. If they can continue to put together strong performances on both sides of the ball, they could make a deep run in the playoffs and add another state title to their trophy case.
3# Somers (Lincolndale)
Somers High School in Lincolndale, New York is a perennial powerhouse in the state of New York high school football. With a talented roster of athletes and an experienced coaching staff, Somers has been consistently one of the top teams in the state. In 2018, the Tuskers went undefeated in the regular season and made it to the semi-finals of the Class A State Championship. The team also won the Section 1 Championship for the fourth consecutive year.
Somers has produced several outstanding athletes over the years, with four players signing Division I scholarships in 2019. That same year, head coach Tony DeMatteo was named Coach of the Year by the New York State Sportswriters Association.
The Tuskers have had a strong showing in the polls throughout the 2020 season. They are currently ranked 3rd in the state, and look primed to make another deep run into the playoffs. With their talented roster and experienced coaching staff, Somers is sure to remain a top contender in New York high school football for years to come.
4# Archbishop Stepinac (White Plains)
Archbishop Stepinac High School in White Plains, New York is ranked fourth in the New York high school football rankings. Stepinac is led by head coach Mike O’Donnell, who has been with the team since 2013. The team is comprised of talented players and hardworking coaches who have worked together to become one of the top teams in the state. Stepinac has been a powerhouse in high school football for many years, and this season looks to be no different. They have several talented seniors returning for the upcoming season, including quarterback Daniel Roman and running back Daquan Hollman. With a high powered offense and a stout defense, Stepinac will be a force to be reckoned with in 2020.
5# Lewis J. Bennett/Olmsted/Middle Early College/East (Buffalo)
Located in Buffalo, New York, the Lewis J. Bennett/Olmsted/Middle Early College/East is a powerhouse school when it comes to high school football. It has an impressive 9-2 record this season, with both losses coming against powerhouses Archbishop Stepinac and Iona Prep. On offense, they’re led by standout running back KJ Clark who has amassed over 1300 yards and 15 touchdowns on the season. The defense is anchored by senior linebacker Dion Green, who is a shutdown force and has also contributed to their offensive production with 4 interceptions. The team also has plenty of young talent in the form of freshmen quarterback Treyvon Davis and receiver Nathan Roberts. With such a deep and talented roster, it’s no wonder the Lewis J. Bennett/Olmsted/Middle Early College/East is currently ranked 5th in the state of New York.
6# Bayport-Blue Point (Bayport)
Bayport-Blue Point High School is a top-ranked school for football in New York. With an impressive team of players, the Blue Point Phantoms have made it to the state playoffs four times in the last six years. They have also won multiple division championships during this time. The Phantoms are known for their well-rounded offensive and defensive strategies, as well as their ability to create plays with great speed. With experienced coaches and talented athletes, Bayport-Blue Point is definitely a top contender for the New York high school football rankings.
Sayville High School is a four-year public high school located in Sayville, New York. It is part of the Sayville Union Free School District and serves students from the hamlets of Oakdale, Bohemia, and Sayville.
Sayville High School is known for its successful football program. The Golden Flashes have been one of the top programs in New York State since they won the 2007 New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA) Class A championship. Since then, they have made multiple trips to the state playoffs, including an appearance in the 2013 NYSPHSAA Class A championship game.
The Golden Flashes are led by head coach Rob Hoss, who has been at the helm since 2010. He has guided the team to seven playoff appearances and a state championship in 2017. He has also produced some of the best players in the area, including former NFL running back Joe McKnight and current Buffalo Bills offensive lineman Ryan Groy.
Sayville is currently ranked 7th in the New York High School Football rankings and looks to make another run for a state championship this season.
8# Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn)
Erasmus Hall, located in Brooklyn, New York, is one of the best high school football teams in the state. With a strong history of success and a roster of talented players, it’s no surprise that they are ranked 8th on our list. They have won multiple state titles and have been consistently competitive in the highly competitive CHSAA division. The team is led by head coach Danny Landberg, who has been at the helm for the past five seasons. Erasmus Hall is sure to be a strong contender for the CHSAA championship this year, and their ranking is well deserved.
9# Maine-Endwell (Endwell)
Maine-Endwell High School, located in Endwell, New York, is ranked 9th in the state’s high school football rankings. The Spartans are led by head coach Matt Gallagher and have been a staple in the top 10 rankings over the past few years. The team is coming off of a 10-2 record in the 2019 season and have consistently been in the playoffs for the past three seasons. They are considered to be one of the best teams in Section 4 and have the talent to make a deep playoff run this upcoming season. The Spartans have a strong offensive attack and stout defense that will be sure to keep them in contention all year long.
10# Garden City
The Garden City Trojans are one of the most decorated teams in New York high school football. Under head coach Tom O’Brien, the Trojans have won four state titles, eight Long Island championships, and six Nassau County Championships. Garden City has had a number of standout players over the years, including NFL running back Joe McKnight and wide receiver Desean Jackson. In addition to their on-field success, Garden City is also known for its high-quality academics and college preparation. All in all, Garden City stands as one of the top teams in New York high school football. Read More Full New York High School Football Rankings